« Previous Post
Next Post »

The Natural Unit of Music is the Experience

May 20, 2007 at 19:44 | Print This Post Print This Post

Nick Carr’s post on the first nine pages of David Weinberger’s new book, Everything is Miscellaneous, is perhaps an ode to the LP, but contains the start of an interesting debate about the packaging of music online - what is the natural unit of music, assuming there is one? Nick quotes David as commenting that “the natural unit of music is the track”, and takes him to task for it. I haven’t read David’s book (still working my way - with great pleasure - through Hitchen’s God is Not Great, but I will get to it), but ignorance of the subject area hasn’t stopped me from commenting before. I’ll admit to stopping in my tracks when I read that reference. I thought that the natural unit was the experience - whatever it might be for the genre or the context.


RSS Feed

One Response to “The Natural Unit of Music is the Experience”


  1. Dave Hyndman (19 comments.)
    May 23rd, 2007 at 10:32

    Funny. I’ve been reading the book and that line (“the natural unit of music is the track”) really jumped out at me. I maintain a belief in the album as a “unit of music” when done right (in the hands of the likes of Springsteen, Neil Young, et al).

    I think the track is the natural unit of crap music or music from artists without the depth and vision to create a real album.