« Previous Post
Next Post »

Geek Claims Wi-Fi Woman Makes Him Sick


It’s a headline I just couldn’t resist, after picking up the thread on the Ripley’s-esque tale of a woman who claims Wi-Fi makes her sick. George Ou would like to run some tests.

Shades of Lakehead’s President Fred Gilbert, who some months ago rejected campus wi-fi there over EMF radiation health concerns (in a move that provoked a characteristically cantankerous reaction from John Dvorak). Shortly after, Gilbert was interviewed by the National Post on the issue and was quoted as saying that since wi-fi was a convenience technology, we ought to wait until we’re satisfied with its safety. I remember being surprised at the thought, because many technologies are seen as a mere convenience when first adopted, and only become essential when they displace their predecessors and are widely adopted. (I’m sure the telephone was seen by many as a convenience when it was first invented.) That seemed an awfully low bar, frankly, especially when viewed in the context of other comments Gilbert made to the effect that many environmental impacts are not apparent for 30 or 40 years.

But I was more bothered by the impression from his reported remarks that his concerns came from a generalized anxiety about EMF radiation, rather than an in context appreciation of wifi as a relative risk. How unsurprising then, to now see individuals emerging claiming specific health concerns. My first thought is that the clamour around stories like Gilbert’s have given the more suggestible among us something new to fret about. We’ll just to have wait for George’s tests.


RSS Feed

2 Responses to “Geek Claims Wi-Fi Woman Makes Him Sick”


  1. George Ou (1 comments.)
    December 7th, 2006 at 06:52

    Here you go. Largest study with over 400,000 test subjects show no dangers in cell phones.

    Cell phones are about 8 million times stronger at 10 millimeters away compared to an Access Point that’s 10 meters away. This is because objects that are 1000 times further away are 1,000,000 times weaker due to the Inverse Square Law of physics. Since cell phones are safe, it’s absolutely crazy to say that Access Points are dangerous.

    Since Cordless phones are 1,000,000 times stronger at 10 millimeters away and everyone at some point in their life has used one (or a Microwave oven), it is ludicrous to claim Wi-Fi Access Points are dangerous or that you can somehow “feel it”. If you’re truly affected by a Wi-Fi Access Point, a cordless phone or microwave oven should outright kill you.

    This is all junk science.


  2. Rob Hyndman (322 comments.)
    December 12th, 2006 at 13:23

    I’m inclined to agree, George - sounds like tinfoil hat stuff to me.